Idea #5: Building a Local Newsletter That Pays You Monthly

Hey buddy,

Today's WiFi Moolah idea is for anyone who knows their city well and likes the idea of getting paid by local businesses to tell people what's happening.

Local Community Newsletters

The Idea: Create a daily/weekly email newsletter covering local events, businesses, and news in your city, then sell ads to local businesses

Example: 6AM City - $10M+ annual revenue across 31 markets, 1.5M daily readers

Why it works:

• Local businesses desperately need to reach engaged local customers

• People want to know what's happening in their community but hate sorting through noise

• One newsletter in a mid-sized city can hit $250K-1M annual revenue

• 6AM City newsletters average $1M/year revenue with just 60K subscribers

• Lower competition than national newsletters

• Local advertisers pay premium rates ($1,500-2,500 per placement)

• Rough Draft Atlanta saw 3x sponsorship revenue growth in 2024

Time investment: 10-15 hours/week to write and curate content, 5-10 hours/week for ad sales initially

Potential income: $2,000-10,000/month per city

Difficulty: Intermediate

Startup cost: $50-200/month

Where I found it: 6AM City case studies, Local Media Association awards, newsletter industry reports showing local newsletters outperforming national ones

Tools you'd need:

• Beehiiv or Substack (newsletter platform - Beehiiv $0-49/month, better for monetization)

• Canva for graphics (free or $15/month)

• Google Forms for event submissions (free)

• Social media accounts (Instagram, Facebook - free)

• Basic website/landing page (optional but helpful)

• CRM for tracking advertisers (free HubSpot or Google Sheets)

The catch:

• Takes 3-6 months to hit 5,000+ subscribers (the minimum for decent ad revenue)

• Daily/weekly publishing schedule is demanding

• Ad sales requires cold outreach and relationship building (uncomfortable for many)

• Competition from existing local media (newspapers, radio, blogs)

• Success tied to your specific city's market (can't easily relocate)

• Needs 50K+ population city to be profitable (smaller towns don't have enough ad budget)

• You become the "face" of the newsletter (harder to sell or automate later)

My take:

This is community-building disguised as a business. If you genuinely like your city and enjoy connecting people with local stuff (restaurants, events, businesses), this can be incredibly rewarding AND profitable.

The key is focusing on positive, useful content - not hard news or politics. You're the "what's happening this weekend" guide, not the investigative reporter.

Real profitable niches within local newsletters:

• Daily morning briefing (what's happening today + weekend events)

• Food & restaurant focus (new openings, reviews, deals)

• Family events & activities (parents are desperate for this)

• Real estate & development updates (agents will sponsor heavily)

• Arts & culture (galleries, theater, music venues)

My Verdict: Would I try it? Maybe, this will be the experiment of the month for the next month. The $250K-1M annual revenue potential per city is legit, but it requires genuine community connection, not just business hustle.

If you want to explore this:

Month 1-2: Build foundation

1. Pick your city (50K-300K population is sweet spot - big enough for advertisers, small enough for less competition)

2. Choose your niche/angle (don't try to cover everything)

3. Set up Beehiiv account and basic landing page

4. Create social media accounts

5. Write 5-10 sample issues to find your voice

6. Launch with email to friends/family and social promotion

Month 3-4: Grow subscribers

1. Post daily on local Facebook groups and Instagram

2. Partner with local businesses for subscriber giveaways

3. Attend local events and promote newsletter

4. Cross-promote with local influencers

5. Run Facebook ads ($5-10/day targeting your city)

6. Goal: 2,000-5,000 subscribers

Month 5-6: Start monetizing

1. Once you hit 3K+ subscribers, start ad outreach

2. Create simple one-page media kit (subscriber count, open rates, demographics)

3. Cold email/call 20-30 local businesses

4. Offer first-time advertiser discount ($500 for first placement)

5. Goal: 3-5 paying advertisers

The actual path successful local newsletters take:

• Months 1-6: Build to 5K subscribers, get first 3-5 advertisers, earn $1,500-3,000/month

• Months 7-12: Grow to 10K-15K subscribers, 10-15 advertisers, earn $5,000-8,000/month

• Year 2: Hit 25K-40K subscribers, 20-30 advertisers, earn $10,000-20,000/month

• Year 3: Mature newsletter at 50K+ subscribers, $15,000-30,000/month, consider second city

Pro tip: 6AM City's model - 70% local ads, 30% national. Local businesses pay MORE per ad than national brands, and they're more loyal long-term.

Ad pricing strategy:

Beginner (under 5K subscribers):

• Header sponsor: $500-800/week

• Mid-newsletter ad: $300-500/week

• Classified/event listing: $50-150/week

Growing (5K-15K subscribers):

• Header sponsor: $1,000-1,500/week

• Mid-newsletter ad: $600-900/week

• Classified/event listing: $100-250/week

Established (15K+ subscribers):

• Header sponsor: $2,000-3,000/week

• Mid-newsletter ad: $1,200-1,800/week

• Multiple ad slots: Package deals at $5K-8K/month

Money math:

Conservative (10K subscribers, 40% open rate):

• 3 header sponsors/month × $1,000 = $3,000

• 4 mid-newsletter ads/month × $600 = $2,400

• 10 event listings/month × $100 = $1,000

• Total: $6,400/month ($76,800/year)

Moderate (25K subscribers, 45% open rate):

• 4 header sponsors/month × $1,500 = $6,000

• 8 mid-newsletter ads/month × $800 = $6,400

• 15 event listings/month × $150 = $2,250

• Total: $14,650/month ($175,800/year)

Aggressive (50K+ subscribers, 45% open rate):

• Like 6AM City's model: $1M+/year

• Monthly breakdown: ~$83,000/month

• This requires full-time team (2-3 people)

Real examples:

6AM City (professional operation):

• 60K subscribers per city

• $1M annual revenue per city

• 2-3 staff per city

• $250K-300K cost to launch new city

Rough Draft Atlanta:

• Focus: Morning news + food/culture sections

• Sponsorship revenue: 3x growth in 2024

• Expanded into niche verticals successfully

Portland Weekly (Portland Press Herald):

• 51.5% open rate (insanely high)

• 33% subscriber growth in 2024

• Hyper-local focus beats generic news every time

Best cities to start in:

Ideal characteristics:

• Population: 100K-300K

• Growing/stable economy

• High percentage of young professionals or families

• Thriving local business scene

• Limited existing local media competition

Examples:

• Chattanooga, TN

• Boise, ID

• Reno, NV

• Fort Collins, CO

• Savannah, GA

• Charleston, SC

• Greenville, SC (where 6AM City started)

Content that performs best:

• Weekend event roundups (always top clicks)

• New restaurant openings

• Local business spotlights

• "Hidden gem" features

• Free/cheap activities for families

• Development/real estate news

• Community hero stories

What NOT to cover:

• Politics (polarizing, kills advertisers)

• Crime (negative, advertisers hate it)

• Controversial local issues

• National news (people get this elsewhere)

Red flags that this might not work for you:

• Your city has under 50K population (not enough ad budget)

• You hate networking and relationship building

• You can't commit to consistent publishing schedule

• You're uncomfortable with self-promotion

• You expect quick money (this takes 6-12 months)

Tomorrow's idea requires zero writing, zero sales calls, and you can start earning this week.

Talk soon,
Kris

P.S. - Do you get a local newsletter in your city? If so, which one and do you actually read it? Hit reply and let me know if this is oversaturated or still wide open.

Your Boss Will Think You’re an Ecom Genius

Optimizing for growth? Go-to-Millions is Ari Murray’s ecommerce newsletter packed with proven tactics, creative that converts, and real operator insights—from product strategy to paid media. No mushy strategy. Just what’s working. Subscribe free for weekly ideas that drive revenue.

Sign up now