Idea #28: Business Broker Side Hustle - $20K-$200K+/Year Connecting Buyers and Sellers

In partnership with

Attio is the AI CRM for modern teams.

Connect your email and calendar, and Attio instantly builds your CRM. Every contact, every company, every conversation, all organized in one place.

Then Ask Attio anything:

• Prep for meetings in seconds with full context from across your business

• Know what’s happening across your entire pipeline instantly

• Spot deals going sideways before they do

No more digging and no more data entry. Just answers.

Start your free trial →

Hey buddy,

Today's WiFi Moolah idea is for anyone with sales skills who wants to make $40K-$180K/year on nights and weekends connecting business buyers and sellers.

Business Broker / M&A Intermediary

The Idea: Connect business owners who want to sell with buyers who want to buy - handle valuation, marketing, buyer screening, negotiations - earn 8-12% commission when deal closes (typically $10K-$100K+ per transaction)

Example: Business brokers earn 8-12% commission on business sales - $500K business = $50K commission, $3M business = $180K+ commission using "Double Lehman" formula - most work on pure commission (no upfront cost to start), minimum fees $10K-$25K per deal

Why it works:

• 10,000+ small businesses sell in the US every year

• Business owners don't know how to sell their business (need broker)

• Buyers don't know where to find good businesses (need broker)

• Pure commission model (you only get paid when deal closes)

• Low barrier to entry (many states don't require license)

• Repeatable: Once you close one deal, sellers and buyers refer you

• Average commission: $50K-$100K per deal for $500K-$1M businesses

• High turnover industry = opportunity for those who stick with it

Time investment: 10-20 hours/week (side hustle)

Potential income: $20,000-$200,000+/year (1-3 deals)

Difficulty: Intermediate to Advanced

Startup cost: $2,000-$10,000 (licensing, website, listings)

Where I found it: Business brokers charging 10-12% commission on deals under $1M, "Double Lehman" formula for $1M-$5M deals (10% on first million, 8% on second, 6% on third, etc.), minimum fees $10K-$25K, some states require real estate license while others have no licensing requirement

Tools you'd need:

• Real estate or business broker license (FREE-$2,000 depending on state)

• Website + marketing materials ($500-$2,000)

• Business listing platforms: BizBuySell, BusinessBroker.net ($100-$500/month)

• CRM for tracking deals: HubSpot or Pipedrive ($0-$100/month)

• Business valuation software or consultant ($0-$500 per valuation)

• Total startup: $2,000-$10,000

The catch:

• Long sales cycles (3-12 months from listing to closing)

• Most deals fall through (only 20-30% of listings actually sell)

• Need to constantly prospect for new sellers

• Commission-only income (months with $0, then $50K payday)

• High rejection rate (sellers say no, buyers ghost)

• Requires sales, negotiation, and finance knowledge

• Licensing requirements vary by state (some require real estate license)

• High turnover: Many brokers quit within first 2 years (no deals closed)

Why this works as a side hustle:

Business brokerage is one of the rare high-income side hustles that actually scales.

Here's why it's perfect for nights/weekends:

Most business owners work during the day. They meet with you:

• After work: 6-8pm showings

• Weekends: Saturday morning coffee meetings

• Lunch breaks: Quick 30-min buyer calls

Your day job actually helps:

• Buyers trust you more (you're not desperate for commission)

• You can be selective (only take good listings)

• Financial stability while you build (no pressure to close bad deals)

• Network from day job can become buyers/sellers

The side hustle advantage:

When a business owner decides to sell their $800K/year restaurant or $2M/year e-commerce site, they don't know:

• What it's worth

• How to find buyers

• How to negotiate the deal

• How to structure financing

• How to handle due diligence

That's where you come in.

You're the middleman connecting:

• Sellers who want to exit their business

• Buyers who want to own a business

The commission structure:

Main Street deals (under $1M):

• Commission: 10-12% of sale price

• Minimum fee: $10K-$25K

• Example: $600K business × 10% = $60K commission

Lower middle market ($1M-$5M):

• Double Lehman formula:

  • 10% on first $1M

  • 8% on second $1M

  • 6% on third $1M

  • 4% on fourth $1M

  • 2% on remainder

• Example: $3M business = $100K + $80K + $60K = $240K commission

Middle market ($5M-$100M):

• Flat commission: 3-6% of sale price

• Retainer fees: $5K-$50K upfront

• Example: $10M business × 4% = $400K commission

The playbook:

Step 1: Get Licensed (If Required)

Check your state requirements:

• States requiring real estate license: California, Florida, Texas (and 10+ others)

• States with no licensing requirement: Some states allow anyone to broker

• Business broker-specific license: Some states have separate broker license

Cost: $500-$2,000 (exam, licensing, education) Timeline: 2-6 months to get licensed

Step 2: Choose Your Niche

Focus on specific business types:

• Restaurants/cafes - High volume, $200K-$1M deals

• E-commerce - Growing niche, $500K-$5M deals

• Service businesses - HVAC, plumbing, landscaping

• Retail - Gas stations, convenience stores, franchises

• SaaS/tech - Higher valuations, $1M-$10M+ deals

Why niche matters: You become the expert, sellers seek you out

Step 3: Build Marketing Presence

Create simple website:

• "I help [niche] business owners sell their businesses"

• Show past deals (when you have them)

• Contact form for sellers

List on platforms:

• BizBuySell ($99-$499/month to list businesses)

• BusinessBroker.net

• Flippa (for online businesses)

• Local networking groups (BNI, chamber of commerce)

Step 4: Find Sellers

Outbound: Cold call business owners age 60+ (retirement), direct mail campaigns, LinkedIn outreach, network with accountants/attorneys who know sellers

Inbound: SEO content ("How to sell a [niche] business"), Facebook/LinkedIn ads, free valuation offers

Conversion rate: 1-2% of outreach converts to listing

Step 5: Sign Listing Agreement

Exclusive agreement (6-12 months): Seller works with you only, you get 10-12% commission, $10K-$25K minimum fee

Step 6: Value the Business

Use SDE multiples: (Revenue - expenses + owner salary) × 2-4x industry multiple. Tools: BizEquity ($100), CPA valuation ($1K-$5K)

Step 7: Market the Business

Create CIM (Confidential Information Memorandum), post on BizBuySell/BusinessBroker.net, email buyer database, contact other brokers

Step 8: Screen Buyers

Pre-qualify every buyer:

• Do they have capital? (Cash, SBA loan approval, investors)

• Are they serious? (Not just tire-kicking)

• Sign NDA before sharing financials

Conversion: 20-50 buyers inquire, 5-10 are qualified, 1-2 make offers

Step 9: Facilitate Deal

Negotiate terms:

• Purchase price

• Earnout structure (seller gets paid over time)

• Non-compete agreement

• Training/transition period

Coordinate:

• Buyer's attorney, CPA, lender

• Seller's attorney, CPA

• Due diligence (buyer verifies financials)

Timeline: 60-120 days from offer to closing

Step 10: Close and Get Paid

At closing:

• Buyer pays purchase price

• Your commission is deducted from seller's proceeds

• You get paid (finally!)

Money math:

Conservative (Year 1, side hustle evenings/weekends):

• Listings signed: 3-5

• Deals closed: 1 (20% close rate)

• Average sale price: $400K

• Commission: 10%

• Earnings: $40K/year (1 × $40K)

• Time: 10-15 hours/week

Moderate (Year 2-3, part-time focus):

• Listings signed: 8-10

• Deals closed: 2-3 (25% close rate)

• Average sale price: $600K

• Commission: 10%

• Earnings: $120K-$180K/year (2-3 × $60K)

• Time: 15-20 hours/week

Aggressive (Year 3+, could go full-time or stay part-time):

• Listings signed: 12-15

• Deals closed: 3-4 (30% close rate)

• Average sale price: $750K

• Commission: 10%

• Earnings: $225K-$300K/year (3-4 × $75K)

• Time: 20-25 hours/week (or transition to full-time)

Best business types to broker:

High-volume, repeatable:

• Restaurants: $200K-$800K, fast turnover

• Gas stations: $500K-$2M, cash flow businesses

• Franchises: $300K-$1M, proven models

High-commission:

• SaaS companies: $2M-$10M, 6-8% commission

• E-commerce: $1M-$5M, growing niche

• Manufacturing: $3M-$20M, complex deals

Easiest to sell:

• Service businesses with contracts (recurring revenue)

• Businesses with real estate included

• Franchises with strong brands

Common mistakes:

• Taking every listing (bad businesses don't sell, waste your time)

• Overvaluing businesses (unrealistic price = won't sell)

• Not pre-qualifying buyers (waste time with tire-kickers)

• Working without exclusivity (seller can cut you out)

• Not staying in touch with buyers (deals come from your network)

• Giving up after 6-12 months (takes time to close first deal)

• Not building buyer database (you need 50-100+ active buyers)

• Poor negotiation skills (deals fall apart at finish line)

Red flags this isn't for you:

• You hate sales and rejection (constant prospecting required)

• You need steady paycheck (commission-only, lumpy income)

• You're impatient (deals take 3-12 months to close)

• You can't handle stress (deals fall apart constantly)

• You're not detail-oriented (legal docs, financials, due diligence)

• You give up easily (high turnover because it's hard)

Pro tips:

• Build buyer database first - Have 50-100 pre-qualified buyers before taking listings

• Niche down - "I sell restaurants in Austin" beats "I sell any business anywhere"

• Partner with lenders - SBA lenders refer buyers to you

• Network with CPAs/attorneys - They know who's selling before they list

• Offer free valuations - Gets sellers talking to you

• Focus on sellable businesses - Profitable, growing, owner not critical to operations

• Under-promise, over-deliver - Tell sellers it'll take 12 months, close in 6

• Track your pipeline - Need 10-20 active listings to close 2-6 deals/year

Licensing by state (examples):

Real estate license required:

• California, Florida, Texas, New York, Illinois

Business broker license:

• Some states have separate broker license

No license required:

• Some states allow anyone to broker (check your state)

Note: Even if not required, getting licensed shows credibility

The realistic timeline (as a side hustle):

Months 1-6: Get licensed (if needed), build website, start prospecting on nights/weekends, sign 1-2 listings, $0 earned Months 7-12: Continue prospecting, sign 2-3 more listings, first deal might close, $0-$40K earned Year 2: Close 2-3 deals while working your day job, $80K-$180K earned Year 3+: Close 3-4 deals/year, $200K-$300K earned, decision point: go full-time or stay part-time?

This works as a side hustle because:

• Most work happens in evenings/weekends (showing businesses, meeting buyers/sellers)

• Prospecting can be done in spare time (calls, emails, networking events)

• Once a listing is marketed, it's mostly passive until buyer appears

• You only need 1-3 deals/year to make $40K-$180K extra income

Reality check:

80% of new business brokers quit within 2 years because:

• They don't close a deal in first 12 months (get discouraged)

• They can't handle rejection (sellers say no constantly)

• They take bad listings (businesses that won't sell)

• They don't build buyer network (no one to sell to)

The side hustle advantage:

• You have income from day job (can wait for right deals)

• Less pressure = better decisions (don't take bad listings)

• Can be selective about who you work with

• Only need 1-2 deals/year to make $40K-$120K extra

The 20% who succeed:

• Commit to 2+ years before judging success

• Work it consistently (10-20 hours/week, not sporadic)

• Niche down (become THE expert in one business type)

• Build systems (prospecting on weekends, buyer database, deal flow)

$80K-$200K/year extra income is realistic after 2-3 years working nights/weekends.

Talk soon, Kris

P.S. - The easiest way to start as a side hustle: Check if your state requires a license (get it if needed, takes 2-6 months). Start with your network - who do you know that owns a business? Have coffee with 5 business owners. Ask: "Ever thought about selling?" Most will say "maybe in 5 years." Stay in touch. When they're ready, you'll be the first call. You only need 1 deal/year at $40K-$60K commission to make this worthwhile. Work it 10 hours/week on nights and weekends. Your day job gives you the financial stability to be patient and selective. Start this month.

Daily news for curious minds.

Be the smartest person in the room. 1440 navigates 100+ sources to deliver a comprehensive, unbiased news roundup — politics, business, culture, and more — in a quick, 5-minute read. Completely free, completely factual.

Sign up now!